Data-Informed Design for the User Experience at Work
With the right tools, metrics, and processes, Cushing Terrell’s Sandi Rudy and Jennifer Moore share how we can develop a better user experience at work.
After months (or is it years now?) of working from home, we’ve had plenty of time to customize the home office just-so, making micro-adjustments to suit our moods and comfort, optimize for online meetings, and account for both expected and unexpected disruptions. Now with pandemic decreasing in severity, and the possibility that we may be expected to be physically present in the workplace or at least consider it as an option, returning to a shared, somewhat distant workplace may bring with it a mixed bag of feelings, notably, a lack of control over the physical environment.
For some, returning to the office is a relief. No more package deliveries, dogs barking in the background of your meeting, family members ducking through the back of your video chat. For others, it means sacrificing the ability to throw open a window for fresh air, have an exercise break, or easily create a quiet space for focus time. But it doesn’t have to be a full tradeoff. There are means and methods for making collaborative workplaces savvy and smart.
How do the elements of your home office impact your creativity and productivity? What about your mood? Your physical health? How do these things help you live out/reinforce your role and your company’s mission, vision, values?
There are aspects of working somewhere other than your home, which have surfaced over the last couple years, that indicate this might be more beneficial than one might suspect. A commute, for instance, can provide proven psychological benefits — the opportunity to mentally and physically switch between the “home” you and “work” you. Additionally, “Zoom fatigue” is real. Breaks from screen time while collaborating with colleagues in the physical workspace can be incredibly productive. The social interactions afforded by an office setting create opportunities to learn from those around you, spontaneously brainstorm, and reinforce a shared mission or purpose.
But just how do we measure the degree to which these positive outcomes are being realized in a given office environment? And how do we leverage this data into human-centered design decisions? These, of course, are the questions we ask ourselves as designers. What are the key metrics needed to continually improve upon the workplace experience? How do we not only design spaces that respond to the learnings already available, but also spaces that allow for continued evolution, adaptation, and information capture? With the right tools, metrics, and processes, we can develop better, user-centered design solutions.
The social interactions afforded by an office setting create opportunities to learn from those around you, spontaneously brainstorm, and reinforce a shared mission or purpose. Credit: Chase Daniels
Making the Workplace Smart
With employee well-being top of mind, smart building technology has increased in prevalence and sophistication in recent years. Prior to the pandemic, designing for smart building technology was largely preparatory and consisted of providing the infrastructure that would enable various technologies down the road. Throughout the pandemic and currently, building owners and clients have been more inclined to utilize smart building features, making immediate use of the preparatory infrastructure, or fully integrating the technology with new construction or renovations.
These technologies, which often include a digital interface to relay critical metrics like indoor air quality, not only help convey a sense of safety, but also aid in sharing about a building’s positive environmental impact with real-time analyses.
Other smart building features might include responsive roller shades as part of an overall daylight harvesting system, automatic water faucets and toilets, and touchless doors, all incorporated into a master control system that can report real-time results for building management.
With the increased focus on safety and well-being, smart building systems have a multi-fold benefit of letting owners and occupants know exactly what measures are in place and how they are impacting the environment, as well as giving building management teams specific data related to the resources they utilize. Users have more visibility into health and safety metrics and are therefore able to return to the office feeling more informed about and in control of their surroundings.
Creating In-Office Ecotones with Vibe Mapping
Ecotone is the scientific term for the transitional area between two different biological communities. These areas are often rich, diverse zones. As a design community, we can learn from this biodiversity to shape the environments where we live and where we work. With a continually shifting workforce dynamic, plus a pandemic changing how we think about shared workspaces, it’s a critical time to consider what makes workplace environments effective, appealing, and accommodating for all types of knowledge workers.
With ecological design thinking applied to circulation, we can leverage community zones where activities blend. This blending of functions and spaces is unique to collaborative environments, i.e., shared workspaces. By intentionally leveraging these ecotones, it’s possible to create buffers to achieve quiet spaces for focus time while also making chance interactions possible at key moments.
To be successful, we must first identify the needs of an ecotone to appropriately design for it, thus ensuring activation of in-between zones, where the desired, diverse activities overlap. One of the tools we use to identify those needs is called vibe mapping, which leverages data to identify these in-between zones. A vibe map is a kind of heat map that documents activity within a space. When worked into the design process, a vibe map can inform where intentional transitions can be utilized to positively impact workers’ perceptions and mentalities, and other ways to maintain happy, healthy, productive teams.
A vibe map is a kind of heat map that documents activity within a space. It can be used to identify and activate in-between spaces in the workplace. Credit: Cushing Terrell
Designing for the User Experience at Work
Once equipped with data provided by post occupancy research (a detailed look at how a facility is meeting the original design objectives and operational requirements), smart building technologies, vibe maps, and other tools, it’s worth making the distinction between data-informed and data-driven design.
Data-driven design is reactive, responding to metrics captured over a period of time and analyzed for key insights. Data-informed design, on the other hand is research based. It centers on first-hand observation and even considers elements that are immeasurable, such as a company’s core mission or their goals for culture. Identifying the client’s core mission and vision orients our data-informed decisions to ensure our solutions are optimal and align with goals related to core values and culture.
Data-informed design leverages the application of Human Centered Design (Design Thinking) methodologies to provide a framework and rigor for the process in sum. Taking this approach ensures the data gathered is paired with first-hand observation and an acute focus on solving for the specific needs of the teams and individuals who will use a particular space.
By executing a design process that includes data and metrics, in unison with design judgements based on observed outcomes, we can develop better, smarter, more human-centered workplace design solutions.